Five Steps to Loyalty Maturity

The 5 steps to Loyalty Maturity

Loyalty maturity can’t be measured just by the length of time that your programme has been running or the number of people you have registered. To reach the holy grail of loyalty maturity your programme needs to have become its own entity, supported and guided by the principles and objectives of your business but with its own budgets, strategies, team and channels.

We can liken the stages of loyalty maturity to growing up:

Concept to Birth

Your programme is in its conceptual stages, it has unlimited possibilities and needs to be shaped and defined. Before implementing anything you should work out what your business needs and why you believe a loyalty programme will help. Once you have your internal ideas then you should conduct some audience interviews to assess what your audience wants. These can be tricky to run as you need to make sure you aren’t ‘leading the witness’.  Most people are going to say yes to ‘free’ rewards so you need to make sure that you understand what your customers like about your business, what they would improve, why they buy from you and what makes them come back. Conduct these interviews with different types of customers - declining, growth, lapsed and active, so that you can get a good cross section of data.

Once you have gathered the data, start to map out the behaviours you want your customers to emulate and, with your customer ‘hat’ on, think about what they would value in return.


Toddling Around

Your loyalty programme needs to find its feet. This stage is twofold: it is about testing boundaries, trying new things, seeing what is possible; it is also about building relationships, making sure that you have the backing of your team, and that they know what you are doing and why.

Test and learn is a popular concept in many industries and yet it rarely happens in loyalty. A loyalty programme gives you an excellent platform and opportunity to try new ideas, gather data and analyse reactions without giving too much away.

Your team should be your biggest advocates so have them on side ready with the right messages and willing and eager to share the news about your programme to customers. They should also feel some ownership of the programme and have the ability to give feedback and share reactions.

At this stage you need to create a feedback and assessment system which enables you to easily monitor, track and analyse performance against your metrics. Listen to the feedback and see whether it tallies with the data you are seeing. Be willing to adapt and change, try new things, see what works and what doesn’t. Remember though: be clear in your communications, be transparent and be relevant.


Teenage Angst

We all remember our teenage years. We thought we knew who we were, then something new popped up and we wanted to change and adapt to suit the new trend or fad. There was all the angst of growing up and wanting to be treated like an adult but still wanting to behave like a child. Your loyalty programme will go through these stages, where ideas you thought worked really well suddenly seem to be failing.

No loyalty programme will continue to perform well without evolvement. There are continual small (sometimes large) shifts in the business landscape, your environment, your team, your product or service and your customers. You need to be able to evolve your programme. Don’t jump into every new trend, make sure it will work for your audience before committing spend or resource. Keep monitoring and assessing performance and relevance and make sure it is staying true to your original objectives. If it isn’t, firstly check that your strategic objectives are still the same and, if they are, then analyse what has changed in your programme. If your original objectives have changed then that’s fine, just go through the same initial process of creating a strategy for your programme and communicating that out to your stakeholders.



Your loyalty programme has now been around for a while, it has responsibilities now, it features in your communication plans, in your advertising, in your internal strategy.

You are rewarding more than just transactions and you have a solid customer base who are invested, active and engaged. You can segment your customers not just by spend, but by a whole range of behaviours. You understand their emotional attachment to your brand and you know where to place your spend to have the biggest impact.

Your loyalty programme is truly embedded in your business. It is a strategic part of the business goals and objectives. It has its own life force, its own team, its own budget lines and its own marketing strategy.

Loyalty maturity is an exciting place to be, it allows you to delve deeper into the psyche of your customers, to understand more about their behaviours and how you can influence them.


Planning for Retirement

Don’t be afraid to exit a programme if you need to. A loyalty programme doesn’t have to be for life. If it isn’t working for you, enact the exit plan you set out right at the start and remember, be transparent, honest and open with your audience.

We hope you don’t need to exit a programme and that you have been able to evolve and learn with your audience. Bring back some of the methods you have used in the other stages to revitalise a programme or to test something new. Continuous evolvement is key to the success of any programme.



About the Author

Melanie Parker

Melanie Parker

Stream’s co-founder, Melanie, became the first British woman to become accredited with the CLMP from The Loyalty Academy. Passionate about all things loyalty, Melanie cuts through the technical jargon and gets to the real business issue. Melanie loves to develop engaging digital solutions that appear simple whilst creating long lasting partnerships that add value to all.


  1. SL_Fivestepstoloyaltymaturity.pdf 9/29/2021 1:57:08 PM


Loyalty is a bigger asset than you think

Loyalty is a bigger asset than you think

How many people are aware that a loyalty scheme (or indeed many web apps) can be treated as a capex-...

Read More
Customer Profiling in Loyalty

Customer Profiling in Loyalty

There are three customer profiling methods that can be utilised to segment and form a profile of you...

Read More
Christmas Quizzing - Wednesday Wisdom

Christmas Quizzing - Wednesday Wisdom

Jacqui hosted our Wednesday Wisdom on Wednesday 15th December where she ran a Christmas Quiz for all...

Read More
How to inspire your team this Christmas

How to inspire your team this Christmas

It's been a crazy year but making sure to keep your team inspired and engaged in the run up to C...

Read More
Click + to add content